|
|
Post by Charmed_boy on May 1, 2007 20:11:33 GMT
It is known that Shannen Doherty's departure from the show was the biggest change on the show. And 2 groups very distinct formed: the ones that agreed, the ones that didn't like it. What is your side ? I personally preferred Shannen. Her episodes were original, slow and exciting. When I say slow, I mean, it gradually added magic. Unlike Alyssa's episodes, where right in her first season, she adds magic at it's top level, not exploring the small facts, like Shannen did. I know she used to put herself in the top of every episode, but in the end, it was nice watching them  Now, when Alyssa took over the show, it was clear that the show lost it's Charm, even fans were feeling "forced" to watch it like I did. It got so much worse in season 7 that I admire how season 8 survived. In quick words, the show turned into a soap opera after Prue's death. |
|
|
|
Post by raciemaep3 on Sept 25, 2008 1:52:13 GMT
I don't know... I actually kinda like Paige. She was a really cool character, and near the end, Prue started becoming a total jerk. Then again, my favorite episode, Awakened, is during Prue's time. Then again, maybe it doesn't matter to me who is on the show as long as Piper is. She was always my favorite character.
|
|
|
|
Post by Charmed_boy on Apr 11, 2009 18:15:49 GMT
I don't know... I actually kinda like Paige. She was a really cool character, and near the end, Prue started becoming a total jerk. Then again, my favorite episode, Awakened, is during Prue's time. Then again, maybe it doesn't matter to me who is on the show as long as Piper is. She was always my favorite character. Perhaps she was cool but she didn't actually fit in the group, I mean, she didn't have history with the other girls, but then again, it was some sort of twist in the series. Call me conservative, but I am in favour of the original plot where the series was more human, and related to simple cases, not to mention the structure of things was more logical, not in favour of what happened after season 4 when everything became so centered on fantasies and it became some sort of a comical series. It was dark and serious in the begining, with Shannen Doherty acting better...So I still stick to my opinion hehe |
|
|
|
Post by MysticFayte on May 5, 2009 21:12:13 GMT
Honestly, I think it's better now that Prues character is gone. She was just so uptight. I'm not saying Shannen was a bad actress, I just didn't enjoy the character she played. Pheobe is my favorite character. Well, I guess she's my favorite because I've met her, but still... Alyssa Milano is my best friend's cousin. I never knew until two years ago when she was at my friends birthday party. Yeah. I freaked out when I saw her. "OHMIGOD, THAT'S ALYSSA MILANO!" Yeah... Alyssa asked if she could smack me. XD
|
|
|
|
Post by Charmed Fan on Jan 16, 2010 22:20:56 GMT
Honestly, I think it's better now that Prues character is gone. She was just so uptight. I'm not saying Shannen was a bad actress, I just didn't enjoy the character she played. Pheobe is my favorite character. Well, I guess she's my favorite because I've met her, but still... Alyssa Milano is my best friend's cousin. I never knew until two years ago when she was at my friends birthday party. Yeah. I freaked out when I saw her. "OHMIGOD, THAT'S ALYSSA MILANO!" Yeah... Alyssa asked if she could smack me. XD That's so cool. What else happened ? |
|
|
|
Post by maddie on May 6, 2010 14:49:33 GMT
i think that it didn't really matter if her character left or not as the show was still as good. having said that she was awesome!! she did alot for the show after leaving as she stayed behind the scenes, it was her choice to be less in front of the camera
|
|
